← Back to all articles

Say the hard thing in the first sentence

Telling someone what they don't want to hear is one of the hardest parts of becoming a manager. Say it in your first sentence, plainly and calmly, using a simple Fact, Impact, Ask structure.

A manager speaking calmly and directly with a team member across a table in a bright office, illustrating a difficult conversation handled well

With insight from Anne Leaver, ILM specialist and management development trainer

How do you tell someone something they don't want to hear?

Say it in your first sentence, plainly and calmly, then stop and listen. The longer you build up to it, the more anxious you both get, and the more likely it is that the real message gets lost.

Many new managers do the opposite. They open with small talk, add a compliment, explain the background, and only reach the point when the other person is already braced for bad news. By then the build-up has made them anxious, and they're only half-listening to what you actually say.

Why we put it off

Difficult conversations feel risky, especially when you've just been promoted. You want to be liked. You don't want to look heavy-handed. And if the person used to be a peer, or a friend, every instinct says to let it go "just this once".

The trouble is that small issues don't stay small. A missed deadline becomes a pattern. A longer lunch becomes the new normal. The rest of the team notices, and the conversation you eventually have is harder than the one you avoided.

What it looks like in practice

In one of our recent New & Aspiring Leaders workshops, trainer Anne Leaver shared a story from her time as an assistant training manager. She was friendly with her small team, and one team member, who lived some distance away, had arranged to take a shorter lunch and finish earlier. One morning she asked to take a full hour for lunch that day. The training timetable was tight, so Anne said no: with more notice she could have rearranged things, but not on the day. The team member took the hour anyway and the schedule was disrupted. When Anne had to deal with it, their closeness made the conversation much harder, and it escalated.

Years earlier, an experienced manager had told Anne she was too friendly with her team. Her lesson for the group: there's a fine line between being approachable and being too close to say no. Setting clear expectations before there's a problem makes the hard sentence easier to say, and easier to hear.

Quick Win: Fact, Impact, Ask

Before the conversation, write your first sentence using three parts:

  1. Fact: what you've seen, without labels. "You've come back from lunch 30 minutes late three times this week."
  2. Impact: why it matters. "It means the phones aren't covered, and others are picking up the slack."
  3. Ask: what you need, or a question. "I need you back by 1.30. What's getting in the way?"

Then stop talking. The silence after a hard sentence feels long, but it gives the other person room to respond, and you'll learn far more from their answer than from anything you add.

A few things to avoid:

  • The compliment sandwich. People hear the praise as a warning and miss the point in the middle.
  • "Some people have said…" Own the message. If it matters to you, say so.
  • Apologising for raising it. You can be warm without saying sorry for doing your job.

If they used to be your peer

It's harder when you're managing people you used to sit alongside. Two things help. First, set expectations with the whole team early, so everyone hears the same standards at the same time. Second, if one person keeps testing the line, have the conversation in private, not in front of others. Being consistent is what makes you credible; treating a friend differently is what the rest of the team will remember.

Build the habit

Saying the hard thing early is a skill, and like any skill it gets easier with practice. Our New & Aspiring Leaders programme covers the move from colleague to manager, including a workshop on managing conflict. The next cohort starts on 6 January 2027.

Get practical tips like this in your inbox every Thursday. Join The Leadership Brief, our weekly newsletter.

Not sure what your managers need? Book a free discovery call.

Continue reading
← Back to all articles